Go to home page

 
Here you willl find reviews of both ENGINE COMICS and other UK COMICS. For further review sites, refer to the LINKS page.
.
  Engine Comics Online
   Matt Brown  (creator)
   Chris Bunting  Webworld, Comics International No 166
   Colin Dinnie, Underfire Comics
   Garen Ewing, King Rat Press
   Pete Ashton, Bug Powder
Seer
   
Mardou, TRS2
   Chris Bunting, Comics International
   Dave West, Deva Comics

Black Harvest Moon
   Andy Lewis, Comics International
   Jez Higgins, TRS2
   Alasdair Stewart
How to Self Publish: A Rough Guide M1
   SFX
   Jon Edwards, Comics International

Fusion Zero
   Andy Luke TRS2
Fusion One
   Alisdair Stuart (Savant Magazine)
   Andy Lewis, Comics International
   Chris Askham, Big Man Comics
   Dave Goodman
Fusion Two
   Shane Chebsey
   Mooncat
 
 
 


Engine Comics Online
Reviewed by Matt Brown, creator

"Glad I finally found engine comics website as I have been looking for a UK based independent collective and here it is. Please sign me up for any junk mail to do with your group."



Engine Comics Online

Reviewed by Chris Bunting, Webworld, Comics International No 166

"Barry Renshaw's Engine Comics produces such titles as REDEYE, FUSION and the phenomenal Rough Guide to Self Publishing. It's also a main player in the Accent UK publishing group. With cool creators bios, external reviews of its titles and a very respectable links section, this solid site really gives a feel as to what's on offer from Engine. 8/10"

Engine Comics Online
Reviewed by Colin Dinnie, Underfire Comics

"I just had the chance to peruse your website and it looks bloody ace…"


Engine Comics Online

Reviewed by Garen Ewing, King Rat Press (www.kingratpress.co.uk)

"I've just had a very enjoyable visit to your website - you've got some worthwhile content up there which kept me reading for much longer than I should have been. Anyway, the main reason I'm writing is to say I hope you don't mind, but I thought you had such a good website I have linked to it from my own. This isn't just to get a link for myself, I don't mind if you do or don't!"



Engine Comics Online

Reviewed by Pete Ashton, BugPowder (www.bugpowder.com)

"I've been watching Barry Renshaw's seemingly tireless efforts to bring together disparate threads of the UK small press scene with some interest over the last couple of days so I was pleased to stumble (somewhat belatedly) on his Engine Comics site. Here you'll find the usual info about his varied comics and anthologies but also a swathe of useful information culled from his Rough Guide to Self Publishing, scene reports and photos. All he needs is a blog!"


Seer

Reviewed by Mardou, TRS2

"SEER: A one-shot story from Engine Comics, ‘Seer’ is the tale of an urban witch doctor called in to solve murder cases in his own unique way. Jonathan Parkes, the witch doctor in question can ‘see’ the last thing a murder victim sees at the point of death. The only drawback is, he has to taste the victim’s eyeballs to share the vision. Nice. He’s an uncanny ‘Cracker’ if you will, and the TV show comparison bears up in other ways - the strength of the writing, the pacing of plot twists, the believable characters. One thing that is missing from the story however, is women. The absence is strongly felt as so much in the story relies on the protagonist’s relationship to his wife, it’s not enough that we are just told about her. We need to see her too, and this omission dents the credibility of the final line alluding to a sexual throb (though I’m trying not to include spoilers here)!

Gary Simpson’s writing is accompanied by deft artwork. From the opening foggy outline of Manchester, to the intricate lab scenes, to the brick fortresses of rows of terraced houses, Lee O’Connor’s artwork isn’t short on detail. Added to this, the more abstract art depicting the ‘vision’ scenes, fuses really well with the more gritty reality. What lets the artwork down is the inking. It’s too spidery-thin and mechanical looking for such a chunky story about humanity in all its gross, indigestible glory.

My favourite thing about ‘Seer’, is that it’s so ugly - and I mean that as a compliment! This is professional looking stuff, yet no attempt has been made to slicken or prettify. The characters are ordinary blokes with weight problems, and this is so refreshing to see in a medium where chiseled jaws and manly brows still rule the roost. All in all then, ‘Seer’ sets a high standard for small press crime fiction and is well worth the read."


Seer

Reviewed by Chris Bunting, Comics International

When a sadistic murderer terrorizes Manchester, DI Sloane calls in Jonathon Parks, a man who possesses a special supernatural talent. The ending might not come as a shock to some - and indeed, be a little too forced - but with Lee O'Connor's solid art and Gary Simpson's sharp dialogue, this is a gory small press tale that should not be overlooked. (CEB) 6.


Seer

Reviewed by Dave West, DevaComics (www.devacomics.com)

Picked this one up at Bristol from Barry Renshaw's Engine Comics stand, right next to us, and part of our Accent UK collective. I was hoping that I'd enjoy it and be able to review it on this site. Guess what.

A story from the pages of X-Files or Millennium, both favourites of mine at their peak, this is a gritty story, well told and illustrated. The only pity is that the story seems to wrap itself up, as I'd like to see further stories told about the central characters. Ah well, you never know.

Well worth picking up if you like X-Files etc.

 

Black Harvest Moon
Reviewed by Andy Lewis, Comics International:

A 22-page A4 complete vampire story. Black Harvest Moon is expertly drawn by the prolific Colin Stanford in a style very reminiscent of David Lapham. The narrative by Terry Stock is purely 'mature readers but is slowed down by an overuse of caption-boxes where dialogue or the artwork alone could be left to tell the story. Overall, a well-packaged and lovingly crafted comic from the Engine Comics group. (AL) 7.



Black Harvest Moon

Reviewed by Jez Higgins, TRS2

It has been five months since the demons appeared in LA ... and opened the city's veins… Black Harvest Moon is the first of a series of one-shot comics that Barry Renshaw's Engine Comics are producing over the next few months. Baz is an enthusiastic comics champion, he's got a good eye and work he publishes is always worth a look. So let's take one ... ... Charting one man's flight from, subjugation by and ultimate transformation into something more terrible than vampires, this is a rivetting read. Terry Stock's script is strong and unsettling, if wordier than generally considered fashionable. The dialogue sparks along, and the narration moves well. This is a horror story, and a very well played one, focussing on one character and his experiences, rather than blood and viscera. The narrative voice adds and expands on what we see, really putting us inside the story.

It leads us carefully and subtly, so that we don't notice just how far we've gone and the very end. Amidst the confusion and despair, Stock even fits in a laugh-out loud joke that doesn't seem out of place. Good work, really good work. Colin Stanford's muscular art is equal to Stock's script. While obviously Kirby influenced with an undercurrent of Alex Toth, it no mere pastiche. It's plaing this is the way he draws, comfortably and with confidence. The storytelling is clear and effective, and generally looks a treat. Unfortunately, it's been rendered slightly fuzzy through being scanned, but this is a minor thing. This comic really couldn't be any better, and at only a pound plus stamps it couldn't be much more of a bargain either. A4, 32pp, £1 + A4 SAE (44p of stamps I reckon) plus age statement from Engine Comics, 8 Avril Close, Reddish, Stockport, SK5 6XH.


Black Harvest Moon

Reviewed by Alasdair Stewart, from www.savantmag.com

I have a thing for the end of the world. It's largely my Dad's fault. As the head of English at the school I went to, he had a certain amount of freedom in dictating the sort of books we studied. Amongst them were Z FOR ZACARIAH, the story of the last person on Earth and what happens when she finds out she's not alone and DAY OF THE TRIFFIDS. TRIFFIDS especially, with it's deserted streets and uniquely bleak worldview sticks in my mind to this day. The silence that greets the main character as he stumbles out into the world was essayed in 28 DAYS LATER but done so much better here. Whilst the carnivorous mobile plants are, to be fair, a bit of a stretch, there's a palpable sense of doom to TRIFFIDS that entranced and terrified me in equal proportion. BHM has the same feel but, if anything, is darker. Where Wyndham's material tends to be basically optimistic, BHM is the first piece of legitimately nihilistic horror I've read in a long time. Here, the world's ended and everything from personal dignity to identity has gone with it.

Five months ago, demons appeared in Los Angeles. They took the city in days and swarmed out from there, the world changing as they moved through it. A few weeks into the invasion, Bobby and Lisa decide to leave their Nevadan home and join the stream of refugees fleeing, amongst other things, a wave of vampirism. They get seperated in an attack and Lisa is taken, replaced by something with her memories, her skin and none of her morals. Trapped between what used to be the woman he loved and the need to escape the herd he's now part of, Bobby finds himself forced to act but with no idea of what to do. BHM is a stunningly bleak piece of fiction, focussing on the relationship between Bobby and Lisa and how her 'condition' affects it.

The exchanges between the two are wonderful, crackling with the sort of familiar banter of a long term couple but with an incredibly dark edge. There's an almost noirish quality at times, with the thing wearing Lisa manipulating Bobby into betraying his friends and even his humanity. In the hands of a lesser writer, this would be misogynistic tripe. However, Stock takes great pains to keep BHM about a great deal more than a vampiric Russ Meyer escapee. This is why the story keeps coming back to their relationship, and the eventual realisation that Lisa needs Bobby as much as he needs her. They are, as Bobby puts it, echoes of the old Lisa to this creature and it's those echoes that lead her to help him out. In it's own black hearted way, BHM is a love story and a remarkably good one at that. In this case, love really does conquer all, be it humanity, vampirism or the end of the world. Ultimately, it's this intelligence that makes BLACK HARVEST MOON. As well as a fantastic take on what happens AFTER the world ends, it's a complex, occasionally touching and often blackly humorous love story.

With expressive, hyper-realistic art from Colin Stanford, this is a quality package. Clever, smart and disturbing, BLACK HARVEST MOON is everything a good horror story should be."

How to Self Publish: A Rough Guide MK 1
Reviewed by Jon Edwards, Comics International.

Carefully produced and researched, this thorough 44-page book covers many aspects of comics publishing- printing, the Internet, ISBN numbers, copyright- and features advice from UK small press creators and distributors, plus an insightful interview with PAGE 45 retailer Stephen Holland. A UK small press directory and a recommended reading section rounds off an essential purchase for budding self-publishers. (JE) 9.

How to Self Publish: A Rough Guide MK 1
Reviewed by SFX (Fahrenheit 451 p 24).

[The 'Rough Guide' is Fanzine of the Month for August. Click SFX cover below to read the glowing review:- Editor]

Click to see review


Fusion Zero

Reviewed by Andy Luke, TRS2

Fusion Zero is a book I've had sitting around for absolutely fucking ages and I'm sorry to the chaps who have put it together. That's Scott Claringbold and Marc Olivent, Jamie Thompson, Barry Renshaw, Adam Bealby and Anthony Mercer. There's not much of a continuity of theme or style but enough guaranteed to be something to make someone happy. Superheroes, paper dolls with psychopathic tendencies), strange travelling tales involving forest spirits, and the obligatory anal self-referencing dialogue of two guys in a comic shop which has enough artistic detail, merit, charm and a keenness for the everyday of dialogue to make it redemptive. Everybody who has put something into this anthology has not failed to surprise me in a manner I'm all the better for. Claringbold & Olivent's work is an improvement on anything they've done before, though still a way to go.

For information, on where to send the 44 pence of stamps for this behemoth, email enginecomics@hotmail.com! It really is absolutely fucking massive! Available for order this diverting read with view - choice recliner accompaniment.



Fusion One

Reviewed by Alasdair Stuart of Savant Magazine (www.savantmag.com/94/reviews.html)

"Two inches. That's all the space you've got to sell yourself in a small shop, the rightmost two inches of your front cover. Sensible designers use that as an excuse or catalyst to design something that isn't the standard comic cover (You know the sort of thing: WELCOME TO THE X-MEN, MONKEY BOY, HOPE YOU SURVIVE THE EXPERIENCE with Monkey Boy's shattered remains being scraped off Wolverines' boot in the background). Get an unusual cover, you get noticed and you sell the comic in those two inches.

Barry Renshaw seems to know this. FUSION Issue 1's front cover is white, with a monochrome head leaning from the top of shot. He looks like he's taken a beaten or is exhausted, slumped over with liquid slowly dripping from the corner of his mouth. At the bottom of the cover, dead centre is FUSION ONE , with all the credits beneath it. End result? An eye-catching and unusual front cover. Which in this case, is a fair reflection of what's inside.

Opening with 'Widdershins' a fantasy series is a brave move, and one that pays off. Fantasy as a genre is all but played out and at first glance, this looks like more of the same. Slaine-like barbarian rides into town as an Inquisition-like organisation tightens it's grip around the surrounding area. However, Bealby's script manages to rise above the cliches of the genre by one simple decision: Not explaining. This is a world with a dialect of it's own and one which is not quite our own and by showing rather than telling us this, Bealby draws the reader in. It's still a little unclear where 'Widdershins' is going but based on this first part, it looks promising.

'Space Redeemer' is less impressive, which is no reflection on Colin Stanford's art. It's visually the prettiest story in the comic, Stanford perfectly capturing the clean lines and ludicrous costumes of '30s and '40s FLASH GORDON . However, the vaguely parodic script that accompanies it doesn't sit well and ultimately the story feels incomplete and un-engaging.

The next story however, is the star of the show. Renshaw and Webb's 'Hinge' plays like a cross between early Bendis and classic conspiracy fiction, mixing visual invention with what promises to be an unusual and detailed plot. The central idea, that a war with parallel dimensions has been fought for the last forty years isn't entirely new but it's handled with such energy and verve that any familiar elements are quickly forgotten. The art is especially impressive here, with Nathan Webb's clean line work making each character distinctive and leading the reader through the complex layouts with ease. Like 'Widdershins' it's unclear where this is going but, again like 'Widdershins' it certainly opens well.

In closing, Jamie Thomspons' 'Flight of the Coldsore' is a welcome and total deviation from the stories that precede it. Chronicling the break up of a relationship, it uses two images to both demonstrate the ebb and flow of conversation and give the story an unusually poignant and at the same time wry tone. It's the smallest and most personal of the stories here and lacks the pyrotechnics and drama of the other three but to my mind it's the most interesting.

The decision to open this anthology with such a mixed bag has definitely paid off. This is a very promising debut and one which at this price is well worth your time. Engine Comics have started strongly and I look forward to seeing where they go next." (Alasdair Stuart)



Fusion One

Reviewed by Andy Lewis, Comics International

"An anthology containing the opening parts to a series of episodic stories edited by Barry Renshaw, including the start to an ambitious swords-and-goblins ten-parter entitled Widdershins by Adam Bealby and Ant Mercer. Plus marks for Colin Stanford's gloriously retro-art on Space Redeemer. Points taken away for a dozen or so pages of ads which tend to slacken the pace somewhat. (AL) 7."


Fusion One

Reviewed by Chris Askham, Big Man Comics

"Good value for money, this one, and a very mixed bag of strips involving barbarian warriors, space enforcers, corporate experimentation and a funny rag dog hanging from the ceiling by its leg. The guys at ENGINE COMICS have got plenty of big ideas and you can't go wrong to grab this for a pound. Better be quick though, its apparently selling very well. Issue two soon to be available."


Fusion One

Reviewed by Dave Goodman, www.bahala-na.co.uk

Following on from last year's Fusion #0 preview, this anthology continues with it's aim of promoting Small Press creators and comics. Widdershins (by Adam Bealby and Ant Mercer) is my favourite, a richly illustrated fantasy inspired by European folklore. In the Kingdom of Binibog, the seeds have been sown for a conflict between the humans and the 'little gods', the spirits of heath and nature. Colin Stanford's Space Redeemer has a pleasantly retro feel, the art and story evoking the sci-fi action stories of early 80's British boy's adventure comics. Jamie Thompson's Flight of the Cold Sore took a while to grow on me. Reproducing the same two images didn't impress me at first, but I did appreciate the exploration of childhood attachments. Editor Barry Renshaw's own Hinge: Gods and Monsters (art by Nathan Webb) is the start of a sci-fi thriller - Elliot Scott is recruited by the Uchronian Commission after he apparently gains the ability to see other dimensions. It's got adverts (for other small press comics) but at only £1, it's good value for money. Well worth a look."



Fusion Two

Reviewed by Shane Chebsey, www.smallzone.co.uk

Somehow issue two has managed to improve on the first with some truly top class stories and art from some of Britain's best self-publishing creators. The highlight for me is Roger Masons beautifully crafted piece. This title is quickly becoming an essential buy.



Fusion Two

Reviewed by Mooncat, www.zumcomics.info/f/fusion.html